Showing posts with label Islam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Islam. Show all posts

September 4, 2026

The Bowe Bergdahl Saga – Is It Finally Over?

 

Bowe Bergdahl’s 2017 desertion and misbehavior before the enemy conviction has been reinstated by a federal court. The court ruled – correctly in my non-lawyer opinion – that a district court judge does not have the authority to interfere in any way with the military justice system. Let’s review this case.


On the night of June 29-30, 2009, U.S. Army Private First Class Bowe Bergdahl deserted his post at Observation Post Mest in Paktika Province, Afghanistan. Bergdahl was assigned as an infantryman to the 1st Battalion, 501st Parachute Infantry Regiment, 4th Brigade Combat Team, 25th Infantry Division. He had enlisted in the Army in 2008.


Bergdahl was captured relatively soon after deserting his post. The exact date is unknown; however, the Taliban released a video of Bergdahl in captivity on July 18, 2009. This began his five years of captivity by the Haqqani network under extremely harsh conditions.


In May of 2014, in a colossal lapse of judgment, the Obama administration agreed to release five extremely dangerous and notorious senior Taliban leaders from the U.S. detention center in Guantanamo, Cuba in exchange for Bergdahl’s release.


On May 31, 2014, Bergdahl was released to a U.S. special operations team at a helicopter landing zone in Afghanistan. The “Taliban Five” were transported to  Qatar who had agreed to hold them and restrict their travel. Chalk up another failure for the Obama team – the "Taliban Five" later all became involved again in operations in Afghanistan.  


Following an investigation to confirm what virtually everyone already knew – on March 25, 2015, the Commanding General of U.S. Army Forces Command authorized charges to be brought against Bergdahl under the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ):


- Article 85 — Desertion with intent to shirk important or hazardous duty


- Article 99 — Misbehavior before the enemy


The charges were referred to a military court for an Article 32 preliminary hearing.


It was noted in the charges that several U.S. troops were injured in attempts to locate Bergdahl after his initial disappearence/desertion. Members of his unit believe that other soldiers lost their lives in these searches.


For those of us who have served in combat zones, these two articles are considered to be as bad as it gets. Desertion (Article 85) is extremely serious and potentially punishable by death if committed in time of war. We can argue over the question of whether Afghanistan was a war or not. This was one of the Obama Administration talking points as several officials and supportive media attempted to downplay Bergdahl’s desertion. At one point, Obama's National Security Advisor Susan Rice declared that Bergdahl "served the United States with honor and distinction." Nothing could be further from the truth.


However, the charge of “misbehavior before the enemy” (Article 99) is the big one. It is explicitly punishable by death or another punishment directed by a court-martial.


In September 2015, the Article 32 preliminary hearing was convened. There were attempts by some in the Obama Administration to downgrade this into a lower-level special court-martial, but in the end, the Army stuck to their guns (no pun intended) and referred the charges to the highest level, a general court-martial. Bergdahl was arraigned at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, on December 22, 2015.


In December 2016, Bergdahl asked President Obama for a pre-emptive pardon ahead of his trial. To his credit, in a rare moment of moral clarity, Obama did not do so.


On October 16, 2017, Bergdahl voluntarily pleaded guilty without a plea bargain and opted for a military judge only trial. Probably a smart move –  presenting these serious charges to a full general court-martial panel in the face of overwhelming inculpatory evidence likely would have resulted in a harsher sentence.*


On November 3, 2017, the military judge sentenced Bergdahl to a dishonorable discharge, reduction in rank to Private (E-1), and forfeiture of pay, but no prison time, despite prosecutors seeking 14 years of incarceration. I agreed with the judge's decision to not impose prison time.


After his sentencing, the military appellate system kicked in. These are serious charges, with a serious sentence – a dishonorable discharge from the armed forces carries serious consequences.

- July 16, 2019 — Army Court of Criminal Appeals (ACCA): Affirmed Bergdahl's conviction and sentence.


- August 27, 2020 — Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces (CAAF): Affirmed the ACCA decision, upholding the conviction.


- February 2, 2021 — Final military appeal: CAAF denied Bergdahl's writ-appeal petition, exhausting his military appellate remedies.


On February 17, 2021, Berdahl’s lawyers filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia asking the court to review the military justice proceedings and declare that Bergdahl's conviction was unconstitutional and should be vacated.


On July 25, 2023, a U.S. District Judge in that court vacated Bergdahl's conviction on procedural grounds.


On September 1, 2026, the D.C. Circuit struck down that decision because a federal district court lacks authority to vacate a court-martial conviction. The court ordered Bergdahl's lawsuit dismissed, leaving his original military conviction in effect. His dishonorable discharge was effectively reinstated.


Eugene R. Fidell, Berdahl’s very capable and experienced attorney said the case is about “the integrity of the military justice system,” and added that “there is a grave command influence problem that has pervaded this case from the very beginning.” Fidell’s team has 45 days to weigh several options for challenging the ruling, including asking the same panel to reconsider or seeking a discretionary review by the Supreme Court.


My take: Give it up, Fidell. The guy is a confessed deserter. He pleaded guilty to that and, even worse, misbehavior before the enemy. He got what he deserved. The prosecution wanted 14 years of incarceration at the U.S. Military Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. I was among those who supported the dishoorable discharge and the non-custodial sentence. His five years at the hands of the Taliban were enough punishment, albeit self-induced. It’s over – move on.


ADDENDUM: When Bergdahl was returned to American control, I was a military analyst for CNN. As such, I was interviewed extensively about this case, and wrote several articles detailing my personal views and analysis (see links below). I stand by every word.


The Bowe Bergdahl exchange - a mixed blessing (June 1, 2014)


Military chiefs support the release of the "Taliban Five" for Sergeant Bergdahl - well, sort of.... (July 12, 2014)


The Bergdahl court-martial recommendation - has someone leaned on the Army? (October 12, 2015)

Bergdahl - the Army does the right thing (March 25, 2015)


Bergdahl - the deflective media campaign begins (March 28, 2015)

__________________
* Personal note: Shortly after I was commissioned, I was selected to be a member of a general court-martial panel. I was ordered to present myself to the military judge (in this case, a USAF colonel). The defense counsel took one look at me, called for a pre-emptory challenge, and asked that I be excused. I was dismissed without saying a word, no explanation other than, “Thank you, Lieutenant, you are excused.”


I asked a mentor, a USAF colonel, what happened. He asked about the case. A staff sergeant had killed his five-year old son in base housing and was being charged with murder. The local police in Denver, Colorado, wanted no part of it – let the Air Force figure it out. 


The colonel explained: "You showed up as required in full service dress ('dress blues') which requires all awards, decorations, and badges to be worn. The defense counsel, also a USAF officer, read your ribbons – he saw a prior service NCO, aircrew wings, nine Air Medals, Vietnam campaign medals – you are the last person he wants judging his NCO client. “


August 23, 2026

The Islamic Society of Monterey County and the Defense Language Institute

Al-Taqwa Mosque, Seaside, California

On a quiet sidestreet in the city of Seaside, California sits a unobtrusive building with a sign in Arabic and English identifying it as the Masjid al-Taqwa (al-Taqwa Mosque) of the Islamic Society of Monterey County.* You may ask yourself, "Why is there a mosque on the Monterey Peninsula?"

The answer to that question involves one of the peninsula's major employers and landholders - the U.S. Army Presidio of Monterey, home of the Defense Language Institute (DLI). DLI is one of the largest and most respected language schools in the country. It trains thousands of members of the U.S. armed forces in dozens of languages used in intelligence, security assistance, diplomatic and exchange positions worldwide. 

DLI has been at the Presidio since 1963 - it's predeccesor, the Army Language School began its instruction there in 1947. In 1963, the Department of Defense consolidated all military foreign language training as DLI.

The requirements for native speakers of dozens of foreign languages to become faculty members drew people from around the world, people of different ethinc and cultural backgrounds, including different religions. It should come as no surprise that many of the new faculty were Muslims - Islam is the second largest religion in the world, closely following Christianity.

I was a student at DLI several times: first at Biggs Field, Texas, for Vietnamese-Hanoi during the war in Southeast Asia, then at the Presidio for basic and intermediate Arabic, and later as an Arabic instructor. During those years, I saw  changes in the demographic makeup of the Arabic language deparment's faculty. 

In my first encounter as a student in 1973-74, most of the instructors were from Iraq and Egypt, with a smattering of Lebanese and Jordanians, and smaller numbers of Palestinians and Syrians, but very few Gulf Arabs.** An inordinate number of these intructors were Christians, much more than the demographics of the Middle East would indicate.

On my second tour as a student a few years later and during my tenure as a faculty member, I did notice a change in the makeup of the faculty. I have been back to speak to the Arabic students over the years, and I think my assessment is still accurate. What I see now is a much broader representation of the Arabic-speaking countries and a decided shift in the religions of the faculty. It appears to be mostly Muslims now.

Unfortunately, this developed into an issue during operations Desert Shield and Desert Storm - the U.S. defense of Saudi Arabia and the liberations of Kuwait, respectively. After the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait in August 1991, some - albeit a small minority - took umbrage at the "rallying around the flag" not just in the country, but on the Presidio as well. 

When asked about it, I had little sympathy for the position of the instructors who claimed to be offended. My comment: "This is a U.S. military facility, training American warriors to execute U.S. foreign policy. If that means military action  against your country of origin, so be it. If it offends you, find another place to work." Again, I stress that this was a small minority. 

There were similar reactions after the al-Qa'idah attacks of September 11, 2001. That tragedy was of such magnitude that even if people were offended by the U.S. response, they knew better than to raise it. I am curious, but do not know, the reaction to the Hamas attacks on Israelis on October 7, 2023.

So, what does this have to do with the Islamic Society of the Monterey Peninsula and its al-Taqwa (pronounced ah-TAQ-wa - the L is silent here***) Mosque? It means "the mosque of piety." 

No great mystery. As native speakers took positions as instructors of the many languages being taught at DLI, faculty members came from many Muslim countries, not just Arabic-speaking countries, but countries such as Indonesia (the largest Muslim population in the world), Pakistan, India, Iran, Turkey, Albania, Afghanistan, etc. 

At that time, there were no existing Muslim houses of worship in the area. A group of Muslim faculty members began meeting in their homes, finally forming the organization now known as the Islamic Society of Monterey County. To the point that it's not always about Arabic-speaking people, one of the founders of the society was an Indonesian, brought in to start the Indonesian and Malay department at the language school. The society began in 1965 and became a nonprofit religious corporation in 1969.

Following the attacks of 9/11, I also noticed an increase in what I would call the "Islamic leanings" of some of the faculty, many of whom I considered close friends - I still do, but the relationship has certainly changed. It is no longer possible to discuss Middle East events with some of them who become almost enraged when speaking about U.S. foreign policy. It's better left alone. I am often tempted to repeat the comments I made after the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait (see above). 

So, in a way, the creation of the Defense Language Insititute at the Presidio of Monterey logically resulted in the creation of the Islamic Society of the Monterey County. It remains a key source of membership in the congregation. 

______________
* There is another mosque in Monterey County - the Salinas Masjid of the Islamic Community of Salinas. The two groups are not affiliated, but often conduct programs, events, and celebrations with each other.
** I am speaking anectdotally here, based on my observations.
*** In Arabic, half of the letters are "solar" and half are "lunar" - solar letters drop the L in the definite article "al-" and double the next (solar) letter.

July 20, 2026

It's "Houthis" with a TH

The Houthis in Yemen - their logo and spokesman

Public Service Announcement for journalists, reporters, anchors, news readers, media analysts, and anyone else who has reason to comment on the Iranian proxy group in Yemen, the "Supporters of God" (أنصار الله) the movement's official name, often rendered as Ansar Allah.
 
They are more commonly called "the Houthis" (الحوثيون). The name "Houthi" comes from the family's surname, not from a religious or tribal title.
 
The movement is named after the al-Houthi (الحوثي) family, particularly its founder, Husayn Badr al-Din al-Huthi (حسين بدر الدين الحوثي)., who launched the movement in the 1990s in Yemen's northern Sa'da Governorate.
 
It is pronounced: "the WHO-thees". I add this to correct the mispronunciation by those who want to sound like they know what they are talking about, changing the Arabic letter ث (thāʾ) — (th as in think) -- to a T, resulting in WHO-tees.
 
Unlike many other languages that do not have the TH sound, Arabic has three different distinct letters that employ that linguistic dental fricative sound.
 
All of those who insist on converting the TH to a T only highlight their lack of understanding of the language and the region.

June 1, 2026

Abdul Carter - What's in a name?

 


Abdul Carter and Jason Dart


Let's talk about "Abdul Carter." 


There was a bit of controversy over New York Giants quarterback Jason Dart. Carter criticized Dart for introducing President Trump at a rally - not that it is any of Carter's business.


I was struck by the name Abdul Carter. I have been dealing with this for decades, mostly among young men who claim to have converted to Islam. 


During Operations Desert Shield and Desert Storm, there was a team of Saudi imams (we called them the God Squad) who would roam the joint commannd center and target Americans for conversion, including me, with offers of money, trips, gifts. They assumed that because I could speak Arabic, I would be a potential convert. I didn't take the time to explain that we in the intelligence services normally learn the languages of our potential foes....


Many of these converts take on what they think are Muslim names. I am not sure if Carter is a convert or was born into a Muslim family. In any case, I would recommend that they learn either a smattering of the Arabic language, or the concept of the 99 attributes of Allah.


Abdul cannot stand alone as a name. 

It is actually the word 'Abd (meaning "servant of") and the Arabic definite article al- (meaning "the"). It is followed by one of the attributes of Allah. 

So when I am introduced to a new convert, and he says his name is "Abdul" - I ask him "'Abd al- WHAT?" Virtually every time, I get a blank stare. This is when I cease to take them seriously. Although I am not a Muslim, I generally know more about it than they do. 

So, in deference to either Carter or his parents, I will acknowledge that his middle name is Jabbar (meaning "the compellor" or "the almighty") - the same as the basketball legend Karim Abdul Jabbar. As with both, the correct transliteration of the Arabic ( عبد الجبار ) would be 'Abd al-Jabbar. It is not a first and middle name, or a middle name and last name - it is one name. 

In the Middle East, if you introduce yourself as Abdul, you will get a puzzled look meaning 'Abd al- WHAT?